UN committee concerned of lack of Saharawi consent over resources

A UN expert human rights committee looking into how Morocco is handling civil and political rights, today expressed deep concerns of the management of the natural resources in Western Sahara, the stalemate in the process of self-determination for the Saharawis, and torture against Saharawis.
Published: 04.11 - 2016 16:16Printer version    
Photo above: Morocco being questioned by the ICCPR human rights committee, 25 October 2016.

The report, which was published on 4 November 2016, is so far only published in French, and is entitled "Observations finales concernant le sixième rapport périodique du Maroc".

The report comes after a year-long process, whereby Morocco has presented to the committee how it deals with the civil and political rights. On 24-25 October, Morocco was questioned by the committee, and today, the anticipated conclusion of the process was presented.

The report, and all associated files, can be dowloaded from the the page of the UN Human Rights Council's Center for Civil and Political Rights. Among the downloadable files, are two submission presented by WSRW to the committee: one 31-page document in 2015 and a 4-page comment in 2016.

The expert ICCPR committee is  "concerned by: a) the limited progress achieved on the question relating to the self-determination of the people of Western Sahara; b) the information according to which the State party has not taken all necessary measures to consult the people of Western Sahara on the exploitation of the natural resources of Western Sahara; c) the presence of the sand wall that limits the free movement of the people of Western Sahara"

This echoes similar findings from the sister committee, CESCR, from last year. Following the CESCR statement in 2015, the Moroccan government responded with rejection of all points, claiming the experts are partial.

In addition to the most substantial paragraph on self-determination referred to above (and copied in its entirety below), the committee was also concerned about:
  • In paragraph 23, torture "in Morocco and in Western Sahara, particularly against people suspected for terrorism, for threat against the state or against the territorial integrity".
  • In paragraph 27, regarding forced disappearance in Western Sahara, and the lack of follow-up of such cases.
  • In paragraph 28, about prison conditions in the territory
  • In paragraph 41, regarding information about disproportionate use of force against human rights defenders.

    Translation into English below by WSRW, [with brackets being comments from WSRW].

    Right to self-determination
    9.   The Committee takes note of the Moroccan initiative for the negotiation of an Autonomy law [statute] for the region of Western Sahara and the additional information submitted by the State party [i.e. Morocco], but it remains concerned by: a) the limited progress achieved on the question relating to the self-determination of the people of Western Sahara; b) the information according to which the State party has not taken all necessary measures to consult the people of Western Sahara on the exploitation of the natural resources of Western Sahara; c) the presence of the sand wall that limits [restricts] the free movement of the people of Western Sahara [as a result of] the reduced access for civilians and the presence of land mines and other explosive munitions along the sand wall which poses danger to the life and safety of the populations which live nearby (Articles 1, 6, and 12 [of the ICCPR]).
    10.   The State party must: a) pursue and strengthen efforts within the context of negotiations concerning the status of Western Sahara required under the auspices of the UN Secretary-General in a manner that ensures realization of the right to self-determination of the people of Western Sahara; b) reinforce  the consultative process with the people of Western Sahara with the goal of obtaining their prior, free and informed consent to the realization of developmental projects and [resource] extraction operations; and c) take the necessary measures to allow the people of Western Sahara to move [travel] freely and in safety from one side of the wall  to the other and pursue a program of de-mining along the length of the wall and compensate victims.

    The version of the document today is labelled "advanced and unedited".



    04.10 - 2019 / 11.09 - 2019Anchoring occupation: Morocco to construct $1bn port in Western Sahara
    09.09 - 2019 / 09.09 - 2019German trade fair should stop promoting Azura, groups say
    09.09 - 2019 / 05.09 - 2019Spanish farmers warn of fraudulent trade from occupied land
    08.09 - 2019 / 06.09 - 2019Protests continue against Ravensdown's blood phosphate imports
    03.09 - 2019 / 03.09 - 2019Kiwis take on New Zealand farmers' blood phosphate imports
    17.06 - 2019 / 27.08 - 2010Support Western Sahara Resource Watch
    21.05 - 2019 / 16.04 - 2019Atlas Copco claims Morocco's phosphate plunder is legal
    17.05 - 2019 / 06.05 - 2019EU elections: how have candidates voted on occupied Western Sahara?
    10.05 - 2019 / 10.05 - 2019'We deserve an answer' from HeidelbergCement
    02.05 - 2019 / 30.04 - 2019Has another cargo of fishmeal from Western Sahara arrived in Germany?
    01.05 - 2019 / 30.04 - 2019Continental dodges question on Western Sahara
    01.05 - 2019 / 17.04 - 2019Greek-Dutch construction group sets up shop in El Aaiun
    30.04 - 2019 / 30.04 - 2019Polisario tries EU Council over new EU-Morocco agricultural deal
    08.04 - 2019 / 04.04 - 2019New report on Western Sahara phosphate industry out now
    21.03 - 2019 / 15.03 - 2019Continental controversial contract in Western Sahara expires next year
    28.02 - 2019 / 25.02 - 2019These are the MEPs who voted for the Western Sahara fish deal
    25.02 - 2019 / 24.02 - 2019Bremen sheds light on massive controversial fishmeal import
    12.02 - 2019 / 12.02 - 2019European Parliament disregards Court and adopts Morocco fish deal
    11.02 - 2019 / 11.02 - 2019Human Rights Watch calls for Court referral of EU-Morocco fish deal
    07.02 - 2019 / 07.02 - 2019110 MEPs want EU-Morocco fish deal referred to Court


    Morocco occupies the major part of its neighbouring country, Western Sahara. Entering into business deals with Moroccan companies or authorities in the occupied territories gives an impression of political legitimacy to the occupation. It also gives job opportunities to Moroccan settlers and income to the Moroccan government. Western Sahara Resource Watch demands foreign companies leave Western Sahara until a solution to the conflict is found.
    EU Court cases on Western Sahara for dummies


    It's not easy keeping up with all the different legal proceedings relating to Western Sahara. For the sake of clarity, here's an overview of the five different cases at the Court of Justice of the European Union.
    Stand up for the Gdeim Izik 25!


    Leading activists from Western Sahara are condemned to sentences ranging from 20 years to life imprisonment in connection to a mass protest in 2010 denouncing the Saharawi people’s social and economic marginalization in their occupied land; the Gdeim Izik protest camp.
    Support Western Sahara Resource Watch


    Help us to protect the natural resources of Western Sahara for the Saharawi people. Support our work by making a donation.
    Report: Moroccan green energy used for plunder


    At COP22, beware of what you read about Morocco’s renewable energy efforts. An increasing part of the projects take place in the occupied territory of Western Sahara and is used for mineral plunder, new WSRW report documents.

    WSRW.org News Archive 2019
    WSRW.org News Archive 2018
    WSRW.org News Archive 2017
    WSRW.org News Archive 2016
    WSRW.org News Archive 2015
    WSRW.org News Archive 2014
    WSRW.org News Archive 2013
    WSRW.org News Archive 2012
    WSRW.org News Archive 2011
    WSRW.org News Archive 2010
    WSRW.org News Archive 2009
    WSRW.org News Archive 2008
    WSRW.org News Archive 2007
    WSRW.org News Archive 2004-2006

    Register for our English newsletter:

    These web pages have been built with the financial support of the trade union Industry Energy