"You may have access to paragraphs 1 to 3 including footnotes 1 to 7". The EU Council replied to WSRW's request for public access to its legal opinion on including Western Sahara in the new EU-Morocco fisheries agreement.
On 22 November 2018, Western Sahara Resource Watch (WSRW) issued a request for access to the EU Council's legal opinion on the new proposed EU-Morocco Fisheries Agreement and its Protocol, that will explicitly be applied to occupied Western Sahara.
The EU's controversial fishing practice in Western Sahara originates from an old Spanish-Moroccan agreement that was signed during the Franco-era. Shortly after, as the Spaniards withdrew from their colony, Morocco went on to occupy large parts of Western Sahara, to UN condemnation.
The EU Council's lawyers have lost four consecutive court cases against the representatives of the Western Sahara people in the Court of Justice of the European Union. Each time, because they had failed to take into account that no deals in Western Sahara can be struck without respecting the Saharawi's right to self-determination.
However, the CJEU's decisions have systematically been ignored by the EU institutions. All evidence suggest that the EU has forgotten to address this issue yet again, as the new deal is up for vote in the European Parliament in February. The UN-recognised representation of the people of Western Sahara, the Polisario Front, has already initiated legal proceedings against the proposed fisheries agreement.
In view thereof, WSRW made a request for access to the Council's legal opinion on the proposed fisheries agreement, under EU legislation granting EU citizens access to documents of the EU Parliament, Commission, or - indeed - Council.
The Council Secretariat responded on 19 December 2018 by sending the first two pages of the legal opinion - the following 14 pages had been deleted.
Find the legal opinion, as the Council chooses to share it with the EU public, here.
The document as sent to WSRW, contains literally only three introductory paragraphs. The accompanying letter, arguing why the legal opinion can't be fully disclosed, is much longer. The argumentation is quasi identical to the explanation for denying WSRW full access to the legal opinion on extending the EU-Morocco trade deal to occupied Western Sahara. Here are the main arguments, and our rebuttal.
Morocco’s Finance Bill for 2027 reveals that four out of six planned green hydrogen projects are located in occupied Western Sahara.
S2H2+Bm has publicly welcomed Morocco’s annexation of Western Sahara, while refusing to clarify whether its planned green hydrogen investments will take place in the occupied territory.
In one of his final statements as UN Secretary-General, António Guterres has made an unequivocal point: the end of MINURSO does not extinguish the inalienable right of the Saharawi people to self-determination. It is a reminder that Morocco cannot declare the Western Sahara question closed simply because the UN mission is leaving.
Moroccan budget documents released in late October reveal that the kingdom allocated tens of thousands of hectares of land in occupied Western Sahara to investment projects.