Fish oil cargo to arrive EU - despite court decision
Article image

A chemical tanker is about to arrive France with fish oil from occupied Western Sahara. The Court of Justice of the EU last year concluded Western Sahara goods are not part of the trade agreement with Morocco.

Published 10 September 2016

The Gibraltar flagged vessel 'Key Bay' on the evening of Thursday 8 September left the port of El Aaiun, in Western Sahara, heading to France. 

This is the first transport of fish products from Western Sahara into the EU that Western Sahara Resource Watch has been able to confirm with certainty, since the Court of Justice of the European Union on 10 December 2015 concluded that Western Sahara goods could not be included in the EU-Morocco trade agreement. 

The charterer of the vessel, Norwegian company Sea Tank Chartering, confirmed to the Norwegian daily business newspaper Finansavisen today that the vessel had picked up a cargo in the territory. The charterer confirmed that this is their first such shipment out of the territory in 2016. Also the owner of the vessel is Norwegian, Gezina AS.

The existence of a cargo on board the vessel can also be deduced from the draught of the vessel - or the vertical distance between the waterline and the bottom of the hull. As 'Key Bay' entered El Aaiun harbour the draught was 5.1 meters, as it departed it was 5.8 meters. Prior to arriving El Aaiun, the vessel did a stopover in Agadir, where the vessel's draught was reduced from 5.4 to 5.1 meters. 

The French pro-Western Sahara group APSO yesterday sent a letter to the customs office in Le Havre, alerting them that the entire or partial cargo originates from Western Sahara.

The European Commission and Council did in fact appeal the decision of the EU court, but did not, surprisingly, request a suspension of the decision of the court. 

"This means that the European institutions have a clear obligation to implement the decision from the first instance. The most obvious way to do that, would be refuse imports from the occupied territory altogether. The arrival of this vessel is controversial, not only in view of international law, but also contrary to the decision of the EU court", stated Erik Hagen of Western Sahara Resource Watch. 

The EU institutions, Morocco, and the Moroccan exporters have, since the decision of the court in 2015, acted has if nothing has changed, and that the decision was ever made. 

The importer is most likely the company Olvea, which fails to answer questions regarding imports from the territory. 
 

The EU court cases

It's not easy keeping up with all the different legal proceedings relating to Western Sahara. For the sake of clarity, here's an overview of the five different cases at the Court of Justice of the European Union.

07 September 2021

EU Court ruling expected on 29 September

The EU Court of Justice will rule on the Union's trade and fisheries agreements with Morocco in occupied Western Sahara on 29 September. 

07 September 2021

Innophos importing heavily from occupied Western Sahara

The Mexican imports of phosphate rock from occupied Western Sahara is picking up pace. New images from Mexico today show a second vessel offloading - while a third is on its way.

05 September 2021

Petroleum from Spain keeps fuelling occupation

Here are all vessels that transported petroleum products from Spanish refineries into occupied Western Sahara last year.

04 September 2021