EU accepted agreement in occupied waters

Interview with the UN's former legal chief, Hans Corell. Swedish Radio, Eko, 22 May 2006

Published 22 May 2006

Swedish Radio, Ekot 
22 May 2006

On Monday afternoon, the EU Ministers of agriculture voted through with a clear majority a fisheries agreement with Morocco. That permits EU fishing vessels to fish offshore the occupied Western Sahara, something which is very controversial. Sweden was the only country to vote against, and was also alone in its protest.

Sweden fought very hard until the end when the EU's agricultural ministers gathered in Brussels for a final decision.

The agreement entails that the EU is to buy fishing quotas from Morocco. It is first and foremost Spanish and Portuguese vessels that will get the right to fish in Western Sahara waters, areas that are occupied by Morocco.

All except Sweden voted yes.
All countries except Sweden voted for the agreement. Sweden did not get any other countries to join the protest. Finland, Ireland and Holland, however, made their own declarations with reservations. 

The Swedish government writes in its protest that the agreement does not fully take into account that Western Sahara is not a part of Morocco's territory. In addition, Sweden is of the view that there are no guarantees that the Western Saharan people will benefit from the fishing agreement.

The UN's former legal chief, the Swede Hans Corell, has previously investigated the question of the right to natural resources in Western Sahara, and he understands the Swedish protests:

“Yes, very much so. It is actually consistent with the opinion that I expressed in a statement that I made to the Security Council when I was the legal chief at the UN. Then, it wasn't about fishing, but about oil exploration. But the problem remains the same,” says Hans Corell.

Controversial territory
Foreign oil companies have previously pulled out of the area, since it is deemed so controversial to exploit the natural resources there.

Hans Corell also believes that one can question the influence of the Western Saharan people at this point.

The UN has for long tried to solve the question of the occupied Western Sahara. The intention is to hold a referendum there, on what the future should be.

"Does not contribute to a solution"
“Great efforts have been made by the UN to solve this question on the status of Western Sahara. And I can hardly believe that such an agreement will contribute to finding a good solution of that question”, says Hans Corell.

It is not clear whether it will have any effect that single EU states such as Sweden makes its own political statements.

Beatrice Janzon

Translation from Swedish by Sahara Update/The Norwegian Support Committee for Western Sahara ________________________________________________________
Source (Swedish): 

Here is the EU Council's legal advice on fishing in occupied waters

Before voting on the new EU-Morocco fish deal in 2018, extending into occupied Western Sahara, several EU Member States asked for legal advice that would determine their vote. WSRW today publishes that influential legal opinion, which appears to miss the ball entirely.
05 March 2020

Hans Corell criticizes EU fisheries in Western Sahara

The former Legal Counsel to the UN Security Counsel, Mr. Hans Corell, comments on the EU's fisheries activities in Western Sahara.

20 November 2019

EU elections: how have candidates voted on occupied Western Sahara?

Are you casting your vote for the EU elections? Find here a complete overview of MEP candidates who have supported the Moroccan occupation of Western Sahara in previous controversial votes. Choose wisely.

17 May 2019

UK High Court confirms EU Court rulings on Western Sahara

The UK Court has concluded that the UK government has acted unlawfully in granting preferential tariff treatment to products from Western Sahara through a deal with Morocco, and in granting fisheries quota's for fishing in Western Sahara under a fish deal with Morocco.

28 March 2019