Here is the controversial statement from Joe Borg
In 2006, the EU fisheries commissioner used the 2002 UN legal opinion on natural resources in Western Sahara to legitimise an illegal fisheries agreement. The author of the legal opinion says Borg must have been "ill advised". See Borg's bizarre reading of the UN text.
Published 06 January 2009


Former UN Under-Secretary General for Legal Affairs, Mr. Hans Corell, at a legal conference in South Africa in December 2008, strongly critizised of the EU fisheries partnership agreement with Morocco, which lets European vessels fish in occupied Western Sahara in violation of international law.

He particularly made reference to a statement from the EU fisheries commissioner Joe Borg, in which Corell's 2002 legal opinion was used to legitimise the unetchical agreement.

"According to an article in EU observer on 9 March 2006 under the title "Commission under fire over Morocco fisheries agreement", EU fisheries commissioner Joe Borg has stated that Morocco is the de facto administrator of Western Sahara and that therefore (my emphasis) the Commission proposal is in conformity with the legal opinion of the United Nations issued in January 2002. See http://euobserver.com/9/21092. If this reference is correct, I am afraid that Commissioner Borg has been ill advised."

This is Borg's bizarre quote: "Morocco is the de facto administrator of Western Sahara. So, the Commission proposal is in conformity with the legal opinion of the United Nations issued in January 2002," he said.

The statement can be seen on the site of EU Observer here [or download].

There is nothing under international law called 'de facto administrator'. There is nothing in the UN legal opinin refering to Morocco as anthing close to being an adminstering power. The UN document explicitly states that Morocco is not.

Here is the EU Council's legal advice on fishing in occupied waters

Before voting on the new EU-Morocco fish deal in 2018, extending into occupied Western Sahara, several EU Member States asked for legal advice that would determine their vote. WSRW today publishes that influential legal opinion, which appears to miss the ball entirely.
05 March 2020

Hans Corell criticizes EU fisheries in Western Sahara

The former Legal Counsel to the UN Security Counsel, Mr. Hans Corell, comments on the EU's fisheries activities in Western Sahara.

20 November 2019

EU Court reaffirms position on Western Sahara

Polisario has a case, but it should be pursued when the time is right, Court implies.

28 February 2019

European Parliament disregards Court and adopts Morocco fish deal

Notwithstanding four consecutive rulings of the EU's highest Court calling such a practice illegal, the European Parliament has just now voted in favour of the EU-Morocco Fisheries Agreement that will be applied to the waters of occupied Western Sahara.

12 February 2019