Moroccan government refuses to disclose fish licence holders
Questions in the Moroccan Parliament regarding the identities of the beneficiaries of fishing licences were denied an answer by the Moroccan government. But leaks in the media indicate that it is mainly Moroccan army generals and defected Saharawis who are on the receiving end.
Published 16 October 2013

Moroccan Fisheries Minister Aziz Akhanouch refused to unveal the names of companies and individuals that are financially profiting on the back of owning fishing licences, claiming that the licences “do not fall within the economy”.

The matter of lifelong fishing licenses authorising access to the rich fish stocks of occupied Western Sahara being handed out to undisclosed benefiaries has been a hot topic in Moroccan media for a few years now. Several newspapers, including Lakome and Akhbar el Youm, have over time commented that these licences that are handed out free of charge are primarily given to senior Moroccan army officials and the royal entourage.

“We await the list of Akhanouch”, independent Moroccan newspaper Lakome headlined shortly after Moroccan Minister of Transport, Abdelaziz Rabah, had published the names of those benefitting from prime inner and intercity routes by orders from high echelons. The publication of the list was in line with the islamist party's promise of transparency, but the content of the list was nevertheless surprising, in the sense that it did not only contain transport companies, but also artists, former Ministers, imams and members of the political beau-monde. Ever since, the Moroccan public has been eager to know who else is receiving profitable licenses in exchange for allegiance to the Morocco’s circles of power.

Anticipating Akhanouch's refusal to reply - he is not of the islamist party, but part of the older power networks - the Moroccan newspaper Akhbar al Youm published a list of the principal possessors of fishing licenses in March 2012. All traces to that list have been removed shortly after, but is still available in the archives of Spanish newspaper El País (or download here).

Heading the list of license-owners is Military Inspector General and Army Commander, Lieutenant General Abdelaziz Bennani. A telegram sent to Washington in 2008 by then U.S. ambassador to Morocco, Thomas Riley, already hinted upon Bennani’s business, according to Wikileaks-cable 08 Rabat 727. "Credible reports indicate that Lt Gen Benanni is using his position as the Commander of the Southern Sector to skim money from military contracts and influence business decisions. A widely believed rumour has it that he owns large parts of the fisheries in Western Sahara. Benanni, like many senior military officers, has a lavish family home that was likely built with money gleaned from bribes. Leadership positions in regional sectors are a significant source of extralegal income for military leaders. "

Head of the Gendarmerie, General Hosni Bensliman, also appears on the list, as does former Inspector-General of the Armed Forces, Abdelhak Kadiri. WSRW believes that Kadiri and Benslimane were associates in ‘Kaben Pêche’ – a company sold to Spanish and Moroccan investors between 2001 and 2004, according to Akhbar al-Youm. Kaben Pêche’s freezer vessels - Abla, Al Hikma, Salima and Sofia - all feature on the European Union’s list of approved fish producers. According to El País, Bensliman and Kadiri own a high number of licenses, which they’ve transferred, not sold, in exchange for money, to Moroccan and Spanish vessel owners. Both Bensliman en Kadiri were subject of an international arrest warrant by French judge Patrick Ramaël - a warrant blocked by the French presidency.

Also listed are colonels Saouss and Ouaâlite. The latter is said to have owned 12 fishing licenses, before teaming-up with a Spanish investor who owns several restaurants in Spain. According to Akhbar al-Youm, most of these licenses were sold at extremely high prices. Among the first to purchase was Moulay Hassan Baraka, father of Morocco’s current Minister of Finance Nizar Baraka.

Bouazza Ikken, former leader of the Democratic Union, once held 18 fishing licenses. But the ‘Prince of Shrimp’, as he’s dubbed by his peers, has sold 10 authorisations. Nevertheless, his family continues to benefit from the remaining eight.

The relatives of former Minister Driss Basri are also on the receiving end of the license-largesse. Basri’s brother-in-law, Abdelmoughit Slimane, owns 56 licenses today – nearly half of the 119 fishing licenses granted to the European Union in exchange for an annual 36 million Euro, under the fisheries agreement which the European Parliament rejected in December 2011.

Albert Lévy, a young Jewish Moroccan who is well-connected to the Palace and owner of the Amnésia nightclub in Rabat – frequented by Mohammed VI and his brother – also holds fishing licenses. Mohamed Zebdi, former associate of General Bennani, etc.

Finally, Saharawi who have sworn allegiance to the Moroccan crown have also been awarded lucrative fishing licenses. Ma’el Ainine Haibatou, former President of the Finances Committee of the Moroccan Parliament, Mohamed Joumani, former Colonel Cherif Dlimi, Cheikh Amer, Hassan Derham and Gajmoula Bint Ebbi, former Polisario-official.

Here is the EU Council's legal advice on fishing in occupied waters

Before voting on the new EU-Morocco fish deal in 2018, extending into occupied Western Sahara, several EU Member States asked for legal advice that would determine their vote. WSRW today publishes that influential legal opinion, which appears to miss the ball entirely.
05 March 2020

Hans Corell criticizes EU fisheries in Western Sahara

The former Legal Counsel to the UN Security Counsel, Mr. Hans Corell, comments on the EU's fisheries activities in Western Sahara.

20 November 2019

EU Court reaffirms position on Western Sahara

Polisario has a case, but it should be pursued when the time is right, Court implies.

28 February 2019

European Parliament disregards Court and adopts Morocco fish deal

Notwithstanding four consecutive rulings of the EU's highest Court calling such a practice illegal, the European Parliament has just now voted in favour of the EU-Morocco Fisheries Agreement that will be applied to the waters of occupied Western Sahara.

12 February 2019